Silicone Sheeting vs Scar Creams, Oils and Gels: Why Silicone Is the Gold Standard
Reviewed by Dr. Jeffrey Weinzweig, MD, FACS, plastic surgeon and Fade Away clinical advisor. Updated November 2026.
International scar management guidelines name silicone, in sheets and gels, as the gold standard for preventing and treating raised scars after surgery. Silicone sheeting is the original and most studied form. It covers the scar around the clock, holds in moisture and takes tension off the healing skin. Silicone scar products are regulated by the FDA as medical devices, with quality rules for how they are made. Most scar creams, oils and lotions are sold as cosmetics, which are made for appearance and are not held to those rules. The trade-off is that sheeting takes more effort to wear than rubbing in a cream.
Why is silicone sheeting considered the gold standard?
It has the longest track record. Doctors have used silicone sheeting on scars since the 1980s, and it is the first-line choice in international scar guidelines written by plastic surgeons and dermatologists. A sheet works around the clock: it seals the scar so moisture stays in, shields it from rubbing, and supports the skin so movement pulls on it less.
Is sheeting better than silicone gel?
Both are medical-grade silicone and both are recommended. Sheeting does more on body scars because it stays on up to 23 hours a day and also takes tension off the skin. Gel is the better choice for the face, small scars and places a strip won't stay. Many patients use both.
What about vitamin E, onion extract, cocoa butter and scar oils?
These have far less evidence behind them than silicone, and most are sold as cosmetics. A cosmetic can moisturize skin and make it look better for a while. It is not regulated to change how a scar heals.
What is the difference between a cosmetic and a medical device?
Under federal law, a cosmetic is for cleansing or improving appearance. A product meant to treat a condition or change how the body works, including how a scar forms, is a medical device or a drug. Medical devices must be registered with the FDA and made under FDA quality system rules. Cosmetics are not subject to those rules.
What should I watch for in scar cream claims?
Words like "removes scars," "repairs skin" or "rebuilds collagen" are treatment claims. A product sold as a cosmetic shouldn't make them. Look for a medical device you can find in FDA's Registration & Listing database. See how to check if silicone scar tape is FDA registered.
What's the downside of sheeting?
It takes more work. You cut it to size, wear it most of the day, take it off to shower and wash it. It can lift where you bend, which is what a small piece of medical tape over the ends is for. Patients who stick with it for 12 weeks or more get the most from it.
Sources
Updated international guidelines on scar management, European Journal of Dermatology, 2014. FDA, Warning Letters Highlight Differences Between Cosmetics and Medical Devices.
Get the free 12-week scar care guide Shop Fade Away